Saturday, December 31, 2005

Someone Has DovBear Pegged To a Tee

Charles Fried, who has been a law professor, judge and Solicitor General, makes some very good points about the NSA wiretapping scandal. Key points:

"We should ask ourselves what concrete harm is done by such a program. Is a person's privacy truly violated if his international communications are subject to this kind of impersonal, computerizerd screening? If it is not, at what stage of further focus do real, rather than abstract and hysterical concerns arise? And to what extent is the hew and cry about this program a symptom of a generalized distrust of all government, or of just this administration?

If of all government, then we are in a state of mind that renders us incapable of defending ourselves from real threats. If of this administration, then can we afford to disarm the only government we have until the result of the next election, which is likely to be as partisan and closely divided as the last?"

Bingo.

(Hat Tip: Instapundit)

No comments: